jump to: verdicts | judges | appeals

Fourth Judicial District Court

The Fourth Judicial District Court is the court of general jurisdiction for San Miguel, Mora and Guadalupe Counties.

Verdicts and Rulings

Of the 13 total outcomes we are aware of for Fourth Judicial District Court, 8 (61%) were decided for plaintiffs and 5 (38%) were decided for the defense. We know of 5 jury trials, 3 bench trials, and 14 cases disposed of by motion.

Prevailing Parties (Jury)

District-wide versus State-Wide

Fourth Judicial District Court

Jury Verdicts

Out of 5 verdicts, 5 (100%) were for the plaintiff and 0 (0%) were for the defense. Prevailing plaintiffs were awarded punitives 100% of the time they asked for them (2/2), at a median ratio of 9.0 times compensatories.

Small firm and pro accounts can see detailed statistics on verdict amounts and puntive ratios here.

Current Judges

Note: Showing only judges who hear civil cases. Click "See all" below to see criminal, childrens, family court, and former judges.

Plaintiff Results
Defense Results
Percent for Plaintiff
Hon. Abigail Aragon (03/01/06 — present)
Hon. Gerald Baca (01/01/08 — present)
Hon. Matthew Sandoval (01/01/08 — present)

Former Judges

Hon. Eugenio Mathis (01/01/92 — 02/28/13)


Year Affirmed Reversed Affirm in part and reverse in part Dismiss Other disposition Grant Deny Public censure Disposition unknown Total
2008 0
2011 0
2012 0
2013 0
2014 0

Pro users can access detailed data regarding appeals.